25 Unusual Pizza Topping Recipes You'll Love at First Bite (2024)

1. Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza: If you use Seamless to order takeout more than you’d like to admit, get creative and find a way to make use of those leftovers before you open up the app again tonight. This exotic dish may just inspire you to get a little more use out of your oven. (via Rasa Malaysia)

2. Beet Pesto Pizza With Goat Cheese: Beets and goat cheese is one combination we can’t get enough of. In this case, sub basil for beets in your pesto sauce for a pairing that is creamy and delicious. (via The Roasted Root)

3. Caramelized Onions, Apples, and Goat Cheese Pizza: Apples and onions may not sound like an ideal match, but when baked, they mix together to create a flavor palette that is interestingly sweet and savory. Add a little thyme and a drizzle of honey and you have yourself a perfectly sweet and fresh pizza you’ll want to serve all summer. (via Jessica in the Kitchen)

4. Thanksgiving Leftover PIzza: Thanksgiving will be faster than we think but also who says you can't add a little cranberry and turkey before then? Here's the perfect leftover recipe to use up all your holiday fixings. (via Brit + Co)

5. Strawberry Balsamic Pizza With Chicken, Sweet Onion, and Applewood Bacon: This blogger raided her almost-empty fridge one night, and in a jam, created quite possibly the most unique pizza we have ever feasted our eyes on. (via The Cafe Sucre Farine)

6. Raspberry Mascarpone Pizza: With a lemon custard, doughy crust and raspberry topping, this dessert is a delicious treat, but still light enough that you won’t feel too guilty afterward. (via Tablespoon)

7. Grilled Honey Sriracha Chicken Pizza: The spice from the Sriracha sauce mixed with honey is a sweet heat that will leave you wanting seconds. Thirds, even. (via Tablespoon)

8. Pizza Nachos: Or Nachos Pizza? We *sometimes* wish you had a little bit of a crunch. Solution? Add nachos! With a doughy crust and crunchy tortillas, this combo is going to blow your mind. (via Brit + Co)

9. Chipotle Cajun Shrimp and Guacamole Pizza: Guacamole on pizza sounds kinda weird, but trust us; dalloped on a bed of gooey cheese and spicy cajun shrimp, it may just be one of the best things you’ve ever eaten. (via Half Baked Harvest)

10. Shrimp Fra Diavolo Pizza: Two of our favorite Italian dishes (pasta and pizza) join forces in this recipe to make one deliciously spicy pie. Paired with your favorite bottle of wine, it’s just the thing for your next date night in. (via Gimme Some Oven)

12. Rhubarb Basil Pizza With Apple Honey BBQ Sauce: Rhubarb on its own is pretty sweet. Combined with basil and a BBQ sauce, however, it’s quite savory and delicious. (via You Pinspire Me)

13. Cookies ‘n’ Creme Dessert Pizza: This rich and creamy dessert pizza is a cookies ‘n’ creme cookie topped with cream cheese frosting, chocolate chips, crumbled cookies, and white chocolate. Basically, you’ll want to keep this recipe on hand for those days when you have a sweet tooth that just can’t seem to be satisfied. (via Girl Versus Dough)

14. Deep Dish Apple Pizza: Just like the classic, except rather than a buttery crust, you get a soft pizza dough. We’re gonna take a wild guess and say this will probably be delicious fresh out of the oven with a big scoop of ice cream on top. (via Brown Sugar)

15. Grilled Blackberry Pizza With Goat Cheese, Pistachios, and Honey: This pie is grilled rather than baked. Serve this savory sweet snack at your next backyard BBQ or pool party. (via Artisan Bread in Five)

16. Chicken Enchilada Pizza: Packed with avocado, jalapeño, chiles, chicken, and much, much more, this pizza is the ultimate substitute if you’re burnt out on celebrating Taco Tuesday. (via How Sweet It Is)

17. Beer Battered Fried Calamari Pizza: If one of your favorite appetizers to order at dinner is deep-fried calamari, then you’ll totally want to try this. Topped with banana peppers and a spicy-creamy hot sauce, it’s basically an explosion of deliciousness in your mouth. (via Bev Cooks)

18. Grilled Peach Pizza With Prosciutto: Peaches are an unexpectedly scrumptious pairing for any savory dish, especially when grilled. The smokey sweetness of the peach mixed with the salt-cured prosciutto and fresh basil leaves are a to-die-for combination. (via Martha Stewart)

19. Chocolate Raspberry Pizza: Okay, so this is just a giant chocolate cookie covered in white chocolate, raspberries, and crunchy almonds. Could there be a better dessert pizza? We think not. (via Dessert for Two)

20. S'mores PIzza: Nothing is more addictive than a s'mores pizza. Bake it in a skillet and you have a delicious twist on the campfire favorite that's impossible to resist. (via Brit + Co)

21. Taco Pizza: This taco pizza combines our two favorite foods into one super satisfying meal. Please excuse us while we grab a margarita and head to the kitchen STAT. (via Jo Cooks)

22. Blackberry Ricotta Pizza With Basil: Ricotta cheese is one of the richest, most velvety, creamiest cheeses out there, so it’s no surprise that it tastes AMAZING alongside a dessert favorite such as blackberries. The basil in this recipe throws in an herbaceous twist, making this pizza a perfect choice for refined palettes. (via The Food Charlatan)

23. Marinated Kale and Whipped Ricotta Pizza: This healthy and fresh creation features hand-rolled dough and marinated kale. What’s the kale marinated in, you ask? Olive oil, honey, and chili garlic paste — talk about a winning trio of flavors. (via How Sweet Eats)

24. Sausage, Apple, and Thyme Breakfast Pizza: As if the idea of breakfast pizza wasn’t creative enough, this gourmet brekky is made with flavors that will knock your socks off. Apple sausage, smoked gouda, mozzarella, gala apple slices, onion, and thyme come together for a truly game-changing pizza pie. (via Recipe Runner)

25. Bacon and Eggs Breakfast Pizza With Hash Brown Crust: In this option, we have an extra bonus for you. This pizza isn't *just* creative in its toppings, it also features an unconventional crust option: hash browns. (via Get Inspired Everyday)

For more yummy pizza recipes and toppings, follow us on Pinterest.

This article has been updated from a previous post.

From Your Site Articles

• 16 Dessert Pizza Recipes That Are a Little Slice of Heaven - Brit + Co ›
• 18 Grilled Pizza Recipes That Bring Pizza Night Outside - Brit + Co ›
• 14 Meatless Pizza Recipes That Prove You're Not Missing a Thing ... ›
• 17 Rustic Veggie Pizzas to Liven Up Your Meatless Monday - Brit + Co ›
• This Cloud Pizza Recipe Makes Being Keto Dreamy - Brit + Co ›
• Want an Excuse to Eat Pizza at Halloween? Make Mummy Pizzas ... ›
• 16 Creative Ways to Top Your Next Pizza - Brit + Co ›
• Recipes, Tools + Upgrades To Level Up Your Homemade Pizza - Brit + Co ›
• 17 Sunny Day Flatbreads and Pizzas for Summer - Brit + Co ›
• Blackberry Pizza - Brit + Co ›