Cheap Recipe: Chewy Homemade Sourdough Croutons (2024)

For a printable version of this recipe and complete ingredients listing, click here.

Cheap Recipe: Chewy Homemade Sourdough Croutons (1)

These chewy bites only take a couple of minutes to make and are indispensible with home-cooked soups and salads.

These yummy bites are a sort of combination of two different recipes: (1) The delicious chewy morsels served at Cracker Barrel, where I waited tables during my college years, and (2) a recipe for “Celestial Croutons” (known to enhance the magical properties of any recipe) in my much-treasured copy of Jana Kolpen’s The Secrets of Pistoulet.

The resulting amalgamation is one of my favorite things to whip up on the fly to serve as companion goodies to homemade soups and salads around the Red Kitchen. And man, oh man, do they make your house smell great! Five minutes in the kitchen, and it smells like you’ve been working in there all day.

The best croutons come from either (1) stale sourdough bread (this is how Cracker Barrel makes them) or (2) English muffins (a delightful discovery I made when the only bread I had around the house was uber-fresh and not dry enough to withstand an oil bath without going soggy). It’s also good to have two options in mind if you’re shopping at a discount, low-variety store because you never know what you’ll come up with in the bread department. You can use regular stale bread; it just won’t be as good. 🙂

I lucked out bigtime this week when I spotted SOURDOUGH ENGLISH MUFFINS on the rack at my local Kroger in

packages priced 10 for $10. I admit it–I was sneaking around at the regular grocery store and not ALDI or Save-A-Lot that day.

So, don’t be shocked if you don’t see sourdough English muffins at the discount joint, but it really doesn’t matter because any of the above options will make generally fantabulous croutons.

And here’s how. Begin by chopping 2 English muffins (tops and bottoms) or a handful of dry bread slices into large, rectangular chunks. Or, if you’re feeling swept away in a magical mood, you can take Jana Kolpen’s advice and whip out any teensy cookie cutters you have and make little stars-and-moons-and-whatnot shaped croutons (hence, “Celestial Croutons”).

While you’re chopping the dry bread, warm a small

Cheap Recipe: Chewy Homemade Sourdough Croutons (3)

See how many croutons just 2 English muffins make?

saucepan over medium heat with a couple tablespoons of olive oil. Sprinkle some garlic powder, onion powder, sea salt and thyme into the oil. (Or, depending on what you’re serving the croutons with, you can experiment with sage, rosemary, savory or other spices. I just like thyme the best.)

Once the oil and spices are warm (only takes a minute or two), drop the chopped bread all at once into the pan and begin stirring immediately with a wooden spoon. (This will help distribute the oil among all of the pieces and avoid having some pieces that are entirely drenched in oil and spice. This is why dry bread works better than fresh–you get a few extra seconds of grace period before that starts happening.)

Keep saucepan at medium heat, stirring bread occasionally. When pieces begin to brown, remove from heat and set on a cool burner until ready to eat. Sprinkle with dried chives if desired. Don’t overcook the croutons or they’ll harden up

Cheap Recipe: Chewy Homemade Sourdough Croutons (4)

It helps to sample them while they cook to ensure quality control. In fact, you might want to make a LOT of extras just to ensure that quality by the end...

like storebought ones. If croutons get finished long before their companion dish, you can always cover the cooling saucepan with foil to hold in moisture.

My two-year-old, Jamie, could smell the bread cooking in his playroom and begged for samples. He never begs for any food that doesn’t have a cartoon character or Star Trek picture on it, so I was a bit floored.

Needless to say, I wasted no time setting him up with a little plate of croutons with some ranch dressing to dip them in. He approved. (See adorable photos of Jamie enjoying his croutons below…)

Jamie also wants you to know the flavor quality is enhanced if you eat them off of an Elmo plate (which has to be pulled out of the sink and washed on demand) instead of the already-clean Spiderman plate in the drawer…

Cheap Recipe: Chewy Homemade Sourdough Croutons (5)

Look at all that ranch dressing on his face. He's being a serious snacker here.

Cheap Recipe: Chewy Homemade Sourdough Croutons (6)

Opening WIDE...

And the toddler’s final verdict is out:

Cheap Recipe: Chewy Homemade Sourdough Croutons (7)

It's a hit! The boy actually likes something he's eating! WOOO WOOO!!!

Cheap Recipe: Chewy Homemade Sourdough Croutons (2024)

FAQs

Why are my homemade croutons chewy? ›

The key to crispy croutons is making sure that they're fully dried out in the oven and crunchy all the way through. They should not be chewy when they come out of the oven. Bake croutons in a single layer on the baking sheet to crisp up the bread, rather than steaming it.

Why is sourdough bread so chewy? ›

Avoid Using Too Much Flour On Your Dough Surface

Try to minimise the amount of rice flour you use and brush off the excess before baking. If you are rubbing your dough with flour before baking to accentuate your scored designs, this too can dehydrate your crust, causing it to be tougher and more chewy.

Is sourdough supposed to be a little chewy? ›

No sourdough should not be wet or gummy inside. Wetness or gumminess is caused by under fermented sourdough that has not been baked through fully. Some sourdough breads can be denser in texture, but they should not be wet or gummy.

Why is my sourdough not crunchy? ›

Your sourdough crust goes soft after cooling because there is still too much moisture in your bread. The baking process should have removed this moisture, but if it's too short, the moisture remains in the crust and softens it as soon as the sourdough cools.

What makes some breads chewy? ›

Over-kneading has a tendency to result in chewy bread. Here's how to tell if you've kneaded enough. Another possibility—you used bread flour when all-purpose flour would do. If a recipe with bread flour turned out chewier than you like, try it with all-purpose and knead only as much as the recipe directs.

Why are my croutons not crispy? ›

Crowding the pan.

Pile the bread cubes on top of each other and they won't have enough space to crisp up and brown. Instead, make sure they're in a even layer.

Why are croutons so crunchy? ›

Tearing bread by hand before coating them in fat and seasoning (think olive oil, flavorful garlic, aromatic herbs, and plenty of salt) and baking it yields croutons with uneven edges that get extra crispy in the oven, creating even more of the crispy, crunchy textures that are the key to making better salads at home.

What happens if you over ferment sourdough? ›

If you over-ferment the dough you run the risk of the gluten structure degrading and the loaf turning into a puddle of goo before your eyes, never to be retrieved and destined for the bin.

How to fix gummy sourdough? ›

tips for avoiding a gummy sourdough loaf - 1) try making a loaf with lower hydration 2) make sure to develop the gluten sufficiently, whether through autolysing, laminating, kneading, or folding 3) make sure to proof long enough 4) make sure to bake long enough and let the loaf cool before cutring #sourdoughtok # ...

What is the best flour for sourdough bread? ›

The best flour blend for creating a new sourdough starter is 50% whole-meal flour (whole wheat or whole rye) and 50% bread flour or all-purpose flour. I recommend a 50/50 mix of whole wheat flour and bread flour. Why do you need to use these two types of flour?

How to stop croutons from going soggy? ›

You can also grill or fry them, but they might be slightly softer in the middle – lovely on a tomato salad, but won't keep as long as drier baked croutons. If you're baking your croutons, make sure they are well-spaced-out on a shallow tray to ensure they crisp evenly and they don't steam, causing them to become soggy.

How to store homemade croutons so they don't get soggy? ›

You don't want any added moisture in the storage container. Once cooled, store the croutons in an airtight container or jar in a cool, dry place. To soak up any excess moisture, you can add a paper towel to the bottom of the container. Stored at room temperature, the homemade croutons will last up to 3 days.

How long will homemade croutons last? ›

How long do croutons last? The expected shelf-life for homemade croutons is about two weeks. Moisture encourages mold, so make sure your croutons are completely dehydrated during the bake and let cool completely at room temperature before storing them away in an airtight container.

What makes sourdough stretchy? ›

Most sourdough recipes contain a lot of water for a good reason: more moisture makes for softer, lighter bread. Since more water in the dough creates more steam, bread expands more as it bakes in the oven. Additionally, more moisture creates a looser gluten network making your dough stretchier.

How do you fix weak sourdough? ›

Method 1: High Feeding Ratio

Sometimes you can remediate a weak, acidic starter with a single high feeding ratio. The most common “high feeding ratios” are 1:5:5 and 1:10:10. These ratios help knock down the acidity of your starter with one large feeding.

Why is my sourdough too soft? ›

This may be due to either your flour not being strong enough, or too much water in your dough, or not building up enough structure in your dough during the pulls and folds. As a starting point, try 25g less water in your dough.

How do you make sourdough more active? ›

10. How do I make my sourdough starter more active?
  1. Keep your starter warm, 74-76°F (23-24°C) or warmer.
  2. Use more whole grains in each feeding.
  3. Feed your starter when it's ripe (not too early, and not too late)
  4. Don't place it into the refrigerator.
Jun 6, 2022

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Allyn Kozey

Last Updated:

Views: 5626

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Allyn Kozey

Birthday: 1993-12-21

Address: Suite 454 40343 Larson Union, Port Melia, TX 16164

Phone: +2456904400762

Job: Investor Administrator

Hobby: Sketching, Puzzles, Pet, Mountaineering, Skydiving, Dowsing, Sports

Introduction: My name is Allyn Kozey, I am a outstanding, colorful, adventurous, encouraging, zealous, tender, helpful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.